Star Trek cited by Texas Supreme Court

The Texas Supreme Court when writing their opinion in Robinson v. Crown Cork and Seal cited Mr. Spock, effectively making him a legal authority for interpreting the Texas Constitution.

Appropriately weighty principles guide our course. First, we recognize that police power draws from the credo that “the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.” Second, while this maxim rings utilitarian and Dickensian (not to mention Vulcan21), it is cabined by something contrarian and Texan: distrust of intrusive government and a belief that police power is justified only by urgency, not expediency.

Footnote 21 reads:

See STAR TREK II: THE WRATH OF KHAN (Paramount Pictures 1982). The film references several works of classic literature, none more prominently than A Tale of Two Cities. Spock gives Admiral Kirk an antique copy as a birthday present, and the film itself is bookended with the book’s opening and closing passages. Most memorable, of course, is Spock’s famous line from his moment of sacrifice: “Don’t grieve, Admiral. It is logical. The needs of the many outweigh . . .” to which Kirk replies, “the needs of the few.”

21 Responses

  1. Pingback: Star Trek Gets Cited by the Texas Supreme Court « The Adams Zone

  2. Pingback: Links for Tuesday « Gerry Canavan

  3. Pingback: Today’s Links October 26, 2010 | Studio 491

  4. Pingback: The Great Geek Manual » Geek Media Round-Up: October 26, 2010

  5. Tyler

    And to think last year my Government AP teacher told me I couldn’t cite Mr. Spock. It was this exact same quote!

  6. Pingback: Star Trek cited by Texas Supreme Court | Penumbra Conundrum

  7. Pingback: Star Trek cited by Texas Supreme Court- Matthew McNutt

  8. Pingback: Geek Radio Daily » Blog Archive » Geek Radio Daily October 28, 2010

  9. Pingback: » Spock Cited By Texas Supreme Court Liberal Values

  10. Nishma

    I remember watching this episode! And in fact, it is not really a logical statement as much as it is a statement of values.

  11. Pingback: It’s logical Jim « Normanomiblog

  12. Pingback: Who To Be This Halloween: Lawyered Spock - MegaGoGo

  13. Pingback: cottage copy » Friday Round-Up: Intergalatic Legal Precedents and the Paris Review

  14. Pingback: Texas Supreme Court cites... the Vulcans - SLUniverse Forums

  15. Pingback: Texas Supreme Court cites Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan @ SciFiFx

  16. Pingback: Super logical Mr. Spock would not be approved by the Texas Supreme Court. Makes total sense that Texas would not listen to logic! « JoeWo Joe Wosik Blog

  17. Pingback: Texas Supreme Court Relies On Extraterrestrial Legal Authority

  18. Pingback: Texas Supreme Court Relies On Extraterrestrial Legal Authority | – Political Viewpoints

  19. Pingback: WTF Oklahomans ban Sharia law - SLUniverse Forums

  20. Pingback: Episode 134: “Your honor, I move that “nuqneH!” be stricken from the record” | Current Geek!